Yes, you can sue a landlord over roaches in New York City. The realistic options are small claims court for money, an HP action in Housing Court to force an exterminator in, and a rent abatement if the landlord sues you first over unpaid rent. Each one answers a different question, and no single case does all three jobs at once.
The Warranty of Habitability
Every one of these claims rests on the same statute. New York's Real Property Law section 235-b writes a warranty into every residential lease, spoken or written: the landlord promises the apartment is fit for human habitation and free of conditions dangerous to health or safety. A lease cannot waive it, and a clause that tries is void. A serious, ongoing roach infestation breaks that warranty, and that breach is what a small claims arbitrator or a Housing Court judge is actually ruling on, whichever route you take.
Free Quotes for Your NYC Apartment
Tell us what the apartment or building needs, from a repair to pest control or a move, and get free quotes from local pros who work in NYC buildings. There is no obligation.
Suing for Money in Small Claims Court
New York City's Small Claims Court, a part of the Civil Court of the City of New York, hears money claims up to $10,000. The claim has to seek money only. A small claims arbitrator or judge cannot order your landlord to call an exterminator, only to pay you. The court fee is $15 for a claim up to $1,000 and $20 for a claim between $1,000 and $10,000, paid by cash, money order or certified check, never a personal check. You file in the county where you or your landlord lives, works, or does business.
What you sue for is the difference in value between the apartment you were promised and the infested one you got, plus documented losses such as ruined food, a pest control bill you paid yourself, or a hotel stay if the infestation forced you out for a night. You are not suing for pain and suffering. That claim does not belong in this court.
HP Actions and the Order to Correct
If what you actually want is a pest control company back in the building, an HP action in Housing Court is the faster route. HPD joins the case as a party, and most conferences end in a settlement or an Order to Correct that sets a legal deadline for the repair, 21 days for a roach violation under HPD's hazard classes. The filing fee is $45, or $70 if you ask for a jury, and the clerk has fee waiver paperwork if you cannot pay. The tradeoff is that the HP judge has no power to award you money for the infestation itself; that remedy lives in small claims or in a nonpayment case, not here. An HP action works best once you have told the landlord in writing that the roaches or bedbugs still are not fixed and gotten nowhere.
Rent Abatement as a Realistic Remedy
A rent abatement, a reduction in what you owe, sounds like the cleanest fix, but it is not something you can simply walk into court and request. An HP judge has no authority to grant one. In practice, tenants get an abatement by withholding rent and then raising the lack of repairs as a defense, or a counterclaim, once the landlord sues over the nonpayment. The judge then weighs how bad the infestation was, how long it lasted, how much of the apartment it reached, and whether the landlord knew and did nothing, and reduces the rent owed for that stretch.
Withholding carries real risk. The landlord can answer by filing a nonpayment case, and you carry the burden of proving the conditions justified holding back the rent. The Legal Aid Society advises tenants to consult a lawyer or an experienced tenant advocate before withholding rent over repairs.
Evidence to Gather Before You Sue
Whichever court you use, the case runs on paper, not on how bad the smell was. Save the following before you file:
- The service request number from every 311 complaint you made about the roaches.
- A printout of the building's HPD violations for pest conditions, with the class and date of each one.
- Dated photos and video of the infestation, retaken as it gets worse.
- Copies of written notice to the landlord or the superintendent, sent by certified mail if you can.
- Receipts or records of any exterminator visits, the landlord's or one you paid for yourself.
Search the building's address in the lookup to pull its HPD violation and complaint history alongside any legal cases already on file, which fills in gaps a tenant's own records usually miss.
HPD tightened part of this record in 2025. Buildings on HPD's Certification Watchlist cannot have a hazardous violation closed on the landlord's word alone; HPD must attempt reinspection at least twice first. If your building is on that list, a certified but unverified roach violation is weaker proof of an actual fix than it looks.
Getting Legal Help Before You Withhold Rent
None of these cases require a lawyer. Small claims court is built for self-represented tenants, and an HPD attorney appears in every HP action, though that attorney represents the city, not you. Legal help matters most before you withhold rent, since a failed defense in a nonpayment case can end in eviction. Income-eligible tenants can reach the Legal Aid Society or a local legal aid clinic for a free case review, and Housing Court's help centers can walk you through the paperwork for either kind of case even without a lawyer.
The Limits of a Lawsuit
Winning does not end your lease on its own. Whether roaches justify walking away from a lease is a separate legal question, and a money judgment or an Order to Correct leaves the tenancy in place either way. The payout is not fixed either: an arbitrator or judge sets the value of your loss and can award less than you asked for. Whichever court you use, the case still runs on the 311 complaints and HPD violations you gathered as evidence, not on the promise of an outcome.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is My Landlord Responsible for Cockroaches in My Apartment?
Yes. New York's warranty of habitability makes the landlord responsible for keeping the apartment free of conditions dangerous to health, and HPD treats roaches as a Class C, immediately hazardous condition with a 21 day deadline to correct. A building-wide or recurring infestation is the landlord's problem to fix.
How Much Does It Cost to Sue My Landlord in Small Claims Court?
The court fee is $15 for a claim up to $1,000 and $20 for a claim between $1,000 and $10,000, paid in cash, money order or certified check. That is the only required cost. You do not need a lawyer, though you can hire one.
What Is the Difference Between an HP Action and Small Claims Court?
An HP action asks a Housing Court judge to order the landlord to fix the roaches, for a $45 filing fee. Small claims court asks an arbitrator or judge for money instead and cannot order any repair. Many tenants end up using both, one for the fix and one for the loss.
Can I Withhold Rent Instead of Suing?
You can, but it is the riskiest of the three options. Withholding invites a nonpayment case from the landlord, where you then have to prove the conditions justified it to win an abatement. Talk to a lawyer or a tenant advocate before you stop paying.
Do I Need a Lawyer to Sue My Landlord for Roaches?
No. Both small claims court and HP actions are built for tenants without a lawyer, and an HPD attorney appears in every HP case, though not on your side. A lawyer matters most if you plan to withhold rent, since that path can end in an eviction case.
What Evidence Do I Need to Sue Over Roaches?
Bring 311 service request numbers, a printout of the building's HPD violations, dated photos, written notice to the landlord, and any exterminator records. The stronger and more dated the paper trail, the easier the case in any of the three courts.
Help Getting the Work Done
Once you know your rights, the next step is getting the problem fixed. Tell us what you need and where you live, and request free quotes from local pros who know NYC building rules.