Skip to content

Most Distressed Buildings in Staten Island

The 50 apartment buildings in Staten Island with the lowest Building Health Scores on November 16, 2026, ranked from open hazardous violations, housing court cases, vacate orders and enforcement programs in HPD and DOB records.

2,158Buildings scored
16.4%Graded D or F
5In the AEP program
25Active vacate orders
A 71.2%B 7.9%C 4.5%D 3.8%F 12.5%

Buildings with six or more apartments are ranked; the full set of Staten Island lots with three or more apartments is scored with the formula on the methodology page. Ties break on open Class C count, then size. Staten Island also has 6 buildings with an HPD finding of tenant harassment.

The 50 Lowest Scores in Staten Island

Fifty lowest-scoring apartment buildings in Staten Island
#BuildingGradeScoreOpen Class COpen Class BOpen HPD casesFlags
11924 Richmond Terrace10302 · 6 apartments · built 2005F0271061
none
245 Curtis Place10301 · 9 apartments · built 1900F044930
none
3283 Jersey Street10301 · 16 apartments · built 1984F0711160
38 heat complaints
4162 St Marys Avenue10305 · 9 apartments · built 1931F027890
none
5194 Seaview Avenue10305 · 15 apartments · built 1975F0451331
12 heat complaints
6514 Richmond Terrace10301 · 16 apartments · built 1931F045960
5 heat complaints
717 St Marks Place10301 · 6 apartments · built 1874F012360
none
8336 Jersey Street10301 · 14 apartments · built 1983F032560
none
9216 Jersey Street10301 · 20 apartments · built 1984F0351121
6 heat complaints
10247 Jersey Street10301 · 31 apartments · built 1984F0591563
14 heat complaints
11210 North Railroad Ave10304 · 20 apartments · built 1966F035880
none
12390 Castleton Avenue10301 · 8 apartments · built 1969F015220
none
13200 Victory Boulevard10301 · 16 apartments · built 1915F024630
8 heat complaints
14160 Heberton Avenue10302 · 43 apartments · built 1920F09720
Vacate order
1598 Taylor Street10310 · 6 apartments · built 1931F01060
Vacate order
16245 Forest Avenue10301 · 13 apartments · built 1968F014350
11 heat complaints
1766A Wolkoff Lane10303 · 84 apartments · built 1985F0632960
84 heat complaints
182 Decker Avenue10302 · 8 apartments · built 1931F08181
5 heat complaints
1917 Oswego Street10301 · 8 apartments · built 1932F08140
6 heat complaints
20369 Jersey Street10301 · 16 apartments · built 1984F017160
AEP17 heat complaints
21225 Park Hill Avenue10304 · 305 apartments · built 1970F02953671
Vacate order142 heat complaints
22454 Van Duzer Street10304 · 52 apartments · built 1966F039800
15 heat complaints
2337 Avon Place10301 · 16 apartments · built 1926F011270
none
24141 St Marks Place10301 · 42 apartments · built 1925F026610
7 heat complaints
25240 Park Hill Avenue10304 · 404 apartments · built 1968F02803501
AEP47 heat complaints
2629 Avon Place10301 · 17 apartments · built 1926F09220
7 heat complaints
2720 Lockman Loop10303 · 40 apartments · built 1992F015680
5 heat complaints
28299 St Marks Place10301 · 70 apartments · built 1951F044540
none
29140 Park Hill Avenue10304 · 403 apartments · built 1966F02432701
69 heat complaints
3020 Merle Place10305 · 64 apartments · built 1964F036410
5 heat complaints
31242 Malden Place10306 · 40 apartments · built 1950F09690
15 heat complaints
3212 Hillcrest Avenue10308 · 36 apartments · built 1969F021170
none
33388 Richmond Terrace10301 · 122 apartments · built 1986F0461301
none
3450 Harbor Loop10303 · 38 apartments · built 1995F03770
6 heat complaints
35319 Jersey Street10301 · 16 apartments · built 1984F06120
34 heat complaints
361290 Richmond Avenue10314 · 72 apartments · built 1966F023651
17 heat complaints
372838 Hylan Boulevard10306 · 84 apartments · built 1950F0141180
12 heat complaints
38150 Trantor Place10302 · 52 apartments · built 1966F06750
none
39316 Jersey Street10301 · 28 apartments · built 1984F09210
16 heat complaints
40137 Heberton Avenue10302 · 28 apartments · built 1933F011120
none
41165 Trantor Place10302 · 93 apartments · built 1966F021911
5 heat complaints
4233 Central Avenue10301 · 55 apartments · built 1930F016411
5 heat complaints
4340 Willow Road West10303 · 52 apartments · built 1973F021181
5 heat complaints
4451 Coursen Place10304 · 30 apartments · built 1971F012100
none
4531 Slaight Street10302 · 44 apartments · built 1997F011340
6 heat complaints
46145 Lincoln Avenue10306 · 148 apartments · built 1964F040970
31 heat complaints
47220 Osgood Avenue10304 · 84 apartments · built 1973F026410
5 heat complaints
48100 Daniel Low Terrace10301 · 105 apartments · built 1966F036362
31 heat complaints
4930 Kimberly Lane10304 · 108 apartments · built 1998F032502
9 heat complaints
50180 Broad Street10304 · 105 apartments · built 2010F032270
6 heat complaints

Open Class B and C counts are HPD violations with status open on November 16, 2026; open HPD cases are housing litigation not marked closed. A low score reflects the public record, not an inspection of any apartment. Owners who have repaired a condition can clear it by certifying the repair with HPD.

Other Boroughs